Person Page - 49

     Mamie Hotchkin was born circa 1863 at Livingland, Choctaw Nation, Indian Territory, USA. She was the daughter of Henry W. Hotchkin and Mary Jane Semple. Mamie Hotchkin was buried circa 1864 at Hotchkin- Ussery Cemetery, at Gay, Choctaw County, OK, USA. She is buried with her father and grandmother Philena.. Mamie died circa 1864 at Livingland, Choctaw Nation, Indian Territory. Not listed in family at publication of Hill..

     Hannah Mariah Hotchkin was born on 1 May 1832 at Mayhew, Lowndes County, MS, USA. The 1860 census gives her age as 28 and born in MS. She was the daughter of Ebenezer J. Hotchkin Rev. and Philena Thatcher. She married John Parker Kingsbury at Indian Territory, USA, on 25 August 1853.² Hannah Mariah Hotchkin died on 3 November 1884 at Boggy Depot, Choctaw Nation, Indian Territory, USA, at age 52.³ She was buried at Boggy Depot Cemetery, at Boggy Depot, Atoka County, OK, USA.

     The birth location is important in this case as it determines if the number of books are correct that claim that her mother carried her on horse back from Mississippi to Indian Territory on the great "Trail of Tears".

     George Thomas Young was born on 25 November 1920.¹ He married Mary Louise Wythe at Lansing, Ingham County, MI, USA, on 22 February 1986.¹ George Thomas Young died on 13 July 2014 at Lansing, Ingham County, MI, at age 93. Reported by Elaine Hotchkin Amos..

     Jane Harriet Hotchkin was born on 30 March 1896 at Chicago, Cook County, IL, USA.¹ She was the daughter of Frank Seymour Hotchkin and Nancy Bates Walker.

     Florence Walker Hotchkin was born on 4 November 1893 at KY, USA. The 1900 census gives her birth as Nov 1893. Gravestone gives exact date. She was the daughter of Frank Seymour Hotchkin and Nancy Bates Walker. Florence Walker Hotchkin married Hiram Earle Austin on 2 April 1912 at Mobile, Mobile County, AL, USA. Book 44, page 146 Mobile County Marriage Records.. Florence Walker Hotchkin died on 25 October 1965 at Mobile, Mobile County, AL, at age 71.¹ She was buried at Pine Crest Cemetery, at Mobile, Mobile County, AL, USA.

     Nancy Bates Walker was born on 28 July 1864 at Richmond, Madison County, KY, USA. The 1900 census gives her birth date as Jul 1864 in KY. She married Frank Seymour Hotchkin at Sedgwick County, KS, USA, on 16 October 1888. Index of Marriages, Record D406 from the files of Midwest Historic & Genealogical Society, as indexed by Bill Pennington.. Nancy Bates Walker appeared on the census of 1900 at Chicago, Cook County, IL, USA. The census lists the family as: Nancy Hotchkin, Jul 1864, Married 12 years, 2 children, 2 living, born KY; dau Florence W., Nov 1893, born KY; dau Irene Harriett, Mar 1896, KY, living on Warren St, (can't read address) some distance from Frank.. She died on 21 June 1908 at Mobile, Mobile County, AL, USA, at age 43.¹ She was buried at Magnolia Cemetery, at Mobile, Mobile County, AL, USA.

     Lowell Stanford Orth was born on 16 October 1903.¹ He married Helen Swift McIntire at NY, USA, on 20 September 1930. Lowell Stanford Orth Jr.. Lowell Stanford Orth died on 3 January 2004 at Guatemala City, Guatemala, at age 100. His son Lowell Stanford Orth Jr. gives his death and burial location..¹ He was buried at Mausaleum Central American Mission, at Guatemala City, Guatemala. His son Lowell Stanford Orth Jr. gives his death and burial location..

     Emma C. Hotchkin was born on 17 January 1882 at Chicago, Cook County, IL, USA. Called C. Emma in the birth records.¹ She was the daughter of Charles Marion Hotchkin and Emma Louise Palmer. Emma C. Hotchkin died on 3 June 1882 at Chicago, Cook County, IL. Died at age 7 months of Malignant Diptheria..² She was buried at Oak Woods Cemetery, at Chicago, Cook County, IL, USA.

     Ebenezer Walner was born on 12 August 1887 at Indian Territory, USA.¹ He was the son of William (Will) Walner Jr. and Lena Hotchkin. He married Frankie Crabtree at OK, USA, circa 1920.² Ebenezer Walner appeared on the census of 1930 at Walker, Garvin County, OK, USA. The census lists the family as: Ebb H. Walner, 41, married at 27, born OK, father born OK, mother born OR, farmer; wife Frankie, 35, married at 21, born TX, parents born TX; son Grant E., 9, born OK.. He died on 23 April 1974 at Norman, Cleveland County, OK, USA, at age 86.¹ He was buried at Mount Olivet Cemetery, at Pauls Valley, Garvin County, OK, USA. Sec 2, Bl 19, lot 6, Sp 9.

     Ebenezer was living with his grandmother Mary J. at the 1900 census of Durant, Choctaw Nation.

     Anna was born at Durant, Bryan County, OK, USA, on 8 April 1911. The 1910 census shows and Infant daughter age 1/2 of 1/12 so it is likely that this birth date should be 1910 instead of 1911.. She was the daughter of Ebenezer Hotchkin DD and Maria Emaline Moore. Anna Jones Hotchkin appeared on the census of 1930 at Sherman, Grayson County, TX, USA. The census lists the family as: Living with her brother Alfred E. and wife Thelma.. She married Mavis Tom Wainwright at TX, USA, after 1930. Anna Jones Hotchkin died on 23 March 1970 at Sherman, Grayson County, TX, at age 58.² She was buried at Cedarlawn Memorial Park, at Sherman, Grayson County, TX, USA.

     Peggy Lou Clark Stephenson refers to her as Anna Jones Wainwright. The middle name of Jones likely came from Robert M. Jones, The Robert M. Jones cemetery in Hugo is named after him and on April 26, 1938, her father held a dedication exercise at the cemetery.

     Dorothy Louise Brose was born on 28 March 1920 at CO, USA.¹ She was the daughter of Arthur Ralph Brose and Mary Philena Hotchkin. She married Waldon Bennett Garlington at CO on 18 June 1955. She resided at Denver, Denver County, CO, USA, in 1994. Dorothy Louise Brose died on 21 April 2011 at Denver, Denver County, CO, at age 91. GARLINGTON, DOROTHY B. 91, born March 28, 1920, died April 21, 2011. Survived by daughter Carol and grandson Alonzo. Preceded in death by husband Waldon. Memorial Service, Friday, April 29th, 2011, 3pm at Montview Boulevard Presbyterian Church, 1980 Dahlia St., Denver. In lieu of flowers, memorials may be made to the Denver Women's Press Club or to the church.
Published in Denver Post on April 27, 2011.² She was buried at Montview Garden Columbarium, at Denver, Dener county, CO, USA.

     Waldon Bennett Garlington was born on 20 May 1920 at Corsicana, Navarro County, TX, USA.^1,2 He married Dorothy Louise Brose at CO, USA, on 18 June 1955. Waldon Bennett Garlington died on 12 October 2001 at Denver, Denver County, CO, USA, at age 81.² He was buried at Montview Garden Columbarium, at Denver, Dener county, CO, USA.

     Charles Curtis (Carl) McIntire Jr. was born on 17 May 1906 at Ypsilanti, Washtenaw County, MI, USA. According to his son, he was born in the manse of the First Presbyterian Church.¹ He was the son of Charles Curtis McIntire and Hettie Daughtery Hotchkin. He married Fairy Eunice Davis on 27 May 1931. He resided at Collingswood, Camden County, NJ, USA, in 1990. Charles Curtis (Carl) McIntire Jr. died on 19 March 2002 at Collingswood, Camden County, NJ, at age 95.^2,1 He was buried at Harleigh Cemetery, at Camden, Camden County, NJ, USA.

     Carl was Pastor of the Bible Presbyterian Church of Collinswood, NJ and President of the International Council Christian Churchs.
     McIntire was born in Ypsilanti, Michigan, the oldest of four children of Charles Curtis McIntire, a Presbyterian minister and M.A. graduate of Princeton University, and Hettie Hotchkin McIntire, a history teacher and later a college dean. Carl spent most of his youth in Oklahoma, where both his maternal grandparents were Presbyterian missionaries in the Choctaw Nation. McIntire completed high school in Durant, in southeastern Oklahoma and attended Southeastern State Teachers College (now Southeastern Oklahoma State University) in Durant. He transfered to Park College, Parkville, Missouri, where he received his B.A. degree before entering Princeton Theological Seminary, New Jersey in 1928 to prepare for the Presbyterian ministry
In the late 1920s, Princeton Seminary was embroiled in the Fundamentalist-Modernist controversy that had disquieted the Presbyterian Church in the United States of America as well as other Protestant denominations. McIntire became a strong supporter of J. Gresham Machen, a noted conservative professor of New Testament. With Machen, McIntire opposed a reorganization of the seminary in 1929 that appeared to strengthen liberal elements in the church, and McIntire followed his mentor and three other professors out of Princeton to the newly founded Westminster Theological Seminary, where he completed his Th.B. degree in 1931.
In May 1931, he married Fairy Eunice Davis (December 23, 1906 – September 13, 1992) of Paris, Texas, whom he had met when they were both students at Southeastern. She had become a high school English teacher while he continued his studies. They had three children. After Fairy Davis McIntire died in 1992, Carl McIntire married Alice Goff, a church office administrator with whom he had worked for many years.
     His biography by Ron Moody said; "Last of the 20th century's fighting religious fundamentalist. Exhaustive preacher, writer and publisher. Known for his motto "A man who will not use his freedom to defend his freedom does not deserve his freedom."

     Charles Curtis McIntire was born on 30 September 1878 at Adams, Seneca County, OH, USA.¹ He was the son of Ambrose Pinkerton McIntire and Mary Frances Kirker. Charles Curtis McIntire died on 25 June 1900 at Mermill, Wood County, OH, USA, at age 21. He married Hettie Daughtery Hotchkin at Mt Pleasant, Sanpete County, UT, USA, on 19 May 1904. Utah marriage records Vol 5, pg 100 Id# 260755.. Charles Curtis McIntire appeared on the census of 1910 at Salt Lake City, Salt Lake County, UT, USA. The census lists the family as: Charles C. McIntire, 31, married once, born OH, parents born OH, clergyman; wife Hettie H., 31, married once, 5 years, 3 children, 3 living; son Charles C. Jr., 3, born MI; dau Helen, 2, born UT; son Hubert, 4/12, born UT..

     Arthur Ralph Brose was born on 19 November 1887 at Chicago, Cook County, IL, USA. Date from 1920 and 1930 census. He was the son of Augusta C. Unknown. He married Mary Philena Hotchkin at San Francisco, San Francisco County, CA, USA, on 26 July 1915. Arthur Ralph Brose registered for the World War I Draft on 5 June 1917 while living at Denver, Denver County, CO, USA. The registration card gave additional information on him: "He gave his birth date and location of birth and said that he was married and lived in Denver. He worked as a machinist.". He appeared on the census of 1930 at Denver, Denver County, CO. The census lists the family as: Arthur R. Brose, 42, married at 27, born IL, parents born Germany; wife Mary P., 50, born OK, parents born OK; dau Dorothy L., 10, born Co, father born IL, mother OK.. He resided at Denver, Denver County, CO, in 1965. Arthur died on 2 December 1965 at Denver, Denver County, CO, at age 78. He was buried at Crown Hill Cemetery, at Wheat Ridge, Jefferson County, CO, USA.

     Fannie (Fay) Hotchkin was born on 4 May 1875 at Caddo, Chickasaw Nation, Indian Territory, USA. She was the daughter of Henry W. Hotchkin and Mary Jane Semple. She married Deman Charles Delzell circa 1900.¹ She resided at Durant, Bryan County, OK, USA, in 1909.² Fannie (Fay) Hotchkin appeared on the census of 1910 at Salt Lake City, Salt Lake County, UT, USA. The census lists the family as: Fanny H. Delzell, 35, widow, no children, born OK, father born MA, mother OH, nurse; living in home of Lorias J. Johnson and his mother Margaret W. Her sister Hettie and husband Charles McIntire lived in Salt Lake at this census.. She married William Nickless McClure at Klamath County, OR, USA, on 16 September 1916. Marriage date found in Oregon Marriages 1906- 1920.. Fannie (Fay) Hotchkin and William Nickless McClure were divorced between 1920 and 1924 at Klamath County, OR. He was married at the 1920 census and divorced at the 1930 census.. Fannie (Fay) Hotchkin married Osa (Asa) Singh on 24 December 1924 at Lewis County, WA, USA. This marriage calls her Fay Delzell Hotchkin..³ Fannie (Fay) Hotchkin died on 1 April 1951 at Shelton, Mason County, WA, USA, at age 75. Death Certificate lists her as Fanny H. Beinsen.. She was buried at Shelton Memorial Park, at Shelton, Mason County, WA, USA.

     In notes of Ebenezer Jr., he refers to Fannie as a preacher and teacher. He also says that she married Dalzell- Beinsen. The compiler suspects that this refers to two separate marriages; first Dalzell and second Brinsin. Volume II of The History of the State of Oklahoma, says that she is now Mrs. Delzell and a teacher in the Presbyterian College.
     Fanny must have been living near her brother Henry in the late 1920's as she and he are the Grantees of property from the Klamath Development Co. on 18 April 1916. She is called Fanny Delzell. On 20 December 1920, Henry Quit Claims property to Fanny McClure, wife of W.N. McClure.
Findagrave.com records say that her death certificate calls her Fanny H. Beinsen.¹

     Joseph Smedley Forrest was born on 10 July 1851 at Indian Territory, USA. Age 51 at 1903 marriage. Birth date from gravestone. He married Cornelia J V Unknown circa 1880. Joseph Smedley Forrest appeared on the census of 1885 at Sans Bois County, Choctaw Nation, Indian Territory. The census lists the family as: J. Smedley Forrest age 34, farmer, 70 acres cultivated, 13 horses, 115 cattle, 250 hogs, 4 bales of cotton, 800 bu corn: Cornelia Forrest, age 27.. He married Katie Nale circa 1887 at OK, USA. He married Lucy K. Hotchkin at Durant, Choctaw Nation, Indian Territory, USA, on 23 June 1903. Marriage Index of 2nd Judicial Dist, US Court, Choctaw Nation. He is called J. S. Forrrest and age 51 of Tamaha and she is Lucy K. Hotchkin, age 27.of Durant..² Joseph Smedley Forrest died on 10 August 1904 at Bryan County, OK, USA, at age 53. Death date from gravestone..³

     William (Will) Walner Jr. was born in 1854 at Indian Territory, USA. This date is not confirmed. He is described as the 3rd child of Dr William Walner and Susan Carter. He was the son of William M. Walner Dr. and Susan Carter. He married Lena Hotchkin at Indian Territory circa 1878.² He resided at Durant, Choctaw Nation, Indian Territory, USA, in 1885. William (Will) Walner Jr. was buried at Phantom Hill Cemetery, at Pauls Valley, Garvin County, OK, USA. No stone has been found for William..

     The original information on the Walner family came from Peggy Stephenson, wife of Charles, who was a son of Mary Lloyd Hotchkin. These notes are believed to be written by Ebenezer Hotchkin Jr.
     Much has been added later from other researchers.
     Mary Semple Hotchkin in her autobiography says that she took in Robert, John, James and Ebenezer and the fifth boy Frank went to live with a neighbor, Mr and Mrs Allen and called them Mama and Papa.³

     Henry Hotchkin was born on 30 October 1866 at Livingland, Choctaw Nation, Indian Territory, USA.¹ He was the son of Henry W. Hotchkin and Mary Jane Semple. He married Luella Johnson at Durant, Choctaw Nation, Indian Territory, USA, in 1889. Date from 1900 census, married 10 years.. He resided at Portland, Multnomah County, OR, USA, in 1891. His occupation is bookkeeper and he boards at Mt Tabor.. Henry Hotchkin was employed by J. M. Arthur & Co in 1893 at Portland, Multnomah County, OR, as He was a Cashier and the City Directory called him Henry T. He and Luella Johnson were divorced on 16 July 1902 at El Paso County, TX, USA.² Henry Hotchkin appeared on the census of 1920 at Klamath Agency, Klamath County, OR, USA. The census lists the family as: Hotchkin, Henry, age 53, b TX; roomer Elizabeth Russell, age 65, widow, b England (his brothers mother-in-law); nephew Eugene L., age 25, b OK.8 101 11 6. He died on 18 January 1936 at Klamath Falls, Klamath County, OR, USA, at age 69. Death Cert 16.^3,4 He was buried on 20 January 1936 at Linkville Pioneer Cemetery, at Klamath Falls, Klamath County, OR, USA. Cemetery records say that he has no stone..

     Little is known about Henry except the information that appears in the O'Hairs Funeral Home records and his Will which was admitted to Probate on 24 January 1936 in Klamath Co., OR. He was a Rancher and Stockman and lived in Beatty, Klamath Co., OR. His wife's name was Luella Holwe or Hilland, but they were divorced at the time of his death (the records are very hard to read and it is not clear whether they are divorced or she is dead, but she did not attend the funeral). The funeral arrangements and payment were made by his daughter, Mrs Marie Baldwin of San Francisco (Marie is also called Mary in the Will). At this date, she lived at 1275 Bay Street, San Francisco. The Will says that his personal property consisted of a team, some cattle and farm machinery; all valued at about $500 and his real estate was 400 acres of pasture land and sage brush, near Beatty, OR. This property was valued at approximately $3,000, but had a mortgage of $1,500. The Will doesn't give an age for Marie but says that daughter Hazel is aged about 40 years. Hazel's address is given as Whitney, OR. Fred is not mentioned so he may be dead at this date. Funeral records say that Henry had lived in Oregon for twenty five years; making his entry into the state about 1911. These records also say that he was born in Texas, where we have him born in Livingland, Indian Territory. The records give his father as Henry Hotchkin, born in Mississippi (known to not be true) and his mother Mary Semple, born in Ohio. Henry Jr.'s birth in Texas may be true as the family lived along the Red River dividing Oklahoma and Texas and were known to have lived on both sides of the river at various times. A real estate record, dated 18 April 1916 shows a transfer from the Klamath Development Co., to Fannie H. Delzell and Henry Hotchkin of Chiloquin. On 20 December 1920 he Quit Claimed property to Fannie McClure and her husband, W. N. McClure, in Klamath Co., OR.
His mother Mary wrote a little about him in her autobiography. She said that he spent several years in Colorado where he was a contractor for the state and was a farmer, rancher and miner.From Colorado he went to Oregon where he was a contractor for the state. She said that he died at Klamath Falls.

     Lena Hotchkin was born on 26 July 1861 at Choctaw Nation, Indian Territory, USA. She was the daughter of Henry W. Hotchkin and Mary Jane Semple. She married William (Will) Walner Jr. at Indian Territory, USA, circa 1878.² Lena Hotchkin died on 14 December 1890 at Pauls Valley, Chickasaw Nation, Indian Territory, USA, at age 29. She was buried at Phantom Hill Cemetery, at Pauls Valley, Garvin County, OK, USA.
     William Walner Dulin said that Lena and William were buried on their farm but it looks as if they were buried on the farm of John Shirley, a Postmaster of Cherokee Town in 1874. The cemetery is presently owned by Fritz Whitaker who lives in California. Rootsweb, Garvin County, OK location has considerable information and pictures on this cemetery. The cemetery is very small with approximatelt 6 burials.
.

     Volume II of the History of the State of Oklahoma, says that at Lena's death, she left five sons living in Durant, OK.³

     Mary Lloyd Hotchkin was born on 31 January 1907 at Durant, Bryan County, OK, USA.² She was the daughter of Ebenezer Hotchkin DD and Maria Emaline Moore. She resided at Dallas, Dallas County, TX, USA, in 1915. She married Charles Corry Stephenson Sr. at Durant, Bryan County, OK, on 6 March 1930.³ Mary Lloyd Hotchkin died on 16 April 1974 at Antlers, Pushmataha County, OK, USA, at age 67.¹ She was buried at Antlers City Cemetery, at Antlers, Pushmataha County, OK, USA.¹

     Mary Lloyd lived in Dallas for a while because she is found in the 1915 Dallas City Directory as a checker with the Dallas Transfer Co. She and Corry Stephenson were married by Rev R.R. Craig of the Durant Presbyterian Church with her mother and sister Lucy as witnessess.

     Christine Moore Hotchkin was born on 14 August 1905 at Durant, Choctaw Nation, Indian Territory, USA.^1,2 She was the daughter of Ebenezer Hotchkin DD and Maria Emaline Moore. She married Fred Barry Ryan at OK, USA. Christine Moore Hotchkin died in April 1974 at Sherman, Grayson County, TX, USA, at age 68.^2,3 She was buried at Highland Cemetery, at Durant, Bryan County, OK, USA. Lot 33.⁴

     Christine's husband Fred Ryan isn't buried in the plot so it is likely that he remarried after her death. Her gravestone says, Christine Hotchkin Ryan, 1905-1974. According to notes presumed to be those of Ebenezer Jr., Fred and Christina had two sons, Barry and Thomas.

     Thomas was born at Durant, Bryan County, OK, USA, on 27 February 1900. Complete birth date comes from his World War I Draft Registration. Dalton-Holmes Funeral records say that he was born in CO..¹ He was the son of Ebenezer Hotchkin DD and Maria Emaline Moore. Thomas Ray Hotchkin registered for the World War I Draft in 1918 while living at Durant, Bryan County, OK, USA. The registration card gave additional information on him: "Thomas gives his age as 18, born 27 Feb 1900. He is presently serving with Co. H of the Oklahoma National Guard. He gives his father, E. Hotchkin as his nearest relative.". He resided at Dallas, Dallas County, TX, USA, in 1920. Thomas died on 10 August 1951 at Vinita, Craig County, OK, USA, at age 51.² He was buried at Highland Cemetery, at Durant, Bryan County, OK, USA. Lot 33.³

     According to the Dalton-Holmes Funeral Home records he died at 4:00 pm, 10 August 1951, of TB of the lungs in Vinita, OK. This may be a place that he went for treatment as these records give his residence as Sherman, TX. The funeral home records say that he was born in Colorado and was single. He is buried adjacent to his parents with a gravestone that says Thomas Hotchkin 1900-1951.
     The 1920-21 Durant City Directory says that he was a student, boarding with his parents at 1501 W. Elm St, but he also found in the 1920 Dallas City Directory, employed by C D Sanders Corp. and rooming at 810 Brooks.¹